She Pop: Will Ellen DeGeneres Make "American Idol" A Gayer Place?

Sady Doyle
View profile »

Sady Doyle is a writer living in Brooklyn, New York. She is the founder of the blog Tiger Beatdown and the author of Trainwreck: The Women We Love to Hate, Mock and Fear, and Why. Her writing has appeared in The GuardianThe Atlantic, The Awl, Buzzfeed, and all across the internet.  ​

I don't really watch American Idol. I did tune in for an episode or two last season, when everyone on the planet was going nuts over the fact that Adam Lambert, a more-or-less openly gay dude and confirmed musical weirdo, had an actual chance at winning it. Unfortunately, the episode that I tuned in for was the one where he sang "Feeling Good," a song I have always really loved coming from Nina Simone, and around the time he hit that bizarre three-year-long air-raid-siren high note ("feelAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAANNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNGG") I was like, "oh. Good for you, Adam Lambert! Allow me to support you through the use of the 'mute' button."

So, no. Aside from seeing the clips that everyone else sees (because they are everywhere, and there is no way not to see them) I'm not a fan. Still, the news that Ellen DeGeneres is going to be replacing Paula Abdul as a judge in the next season of the show is interesting.

The most aggressively wholesome celebrity in America


 Hey guys, what's up? Just sittin' around, bein' wholesome.


To be entirely honest, my first reaction was just deep relief that they hadn't gone with Quentin Tarantino. But, for those less Tarantino-averse and Idol-friendly than I, it's big news, which has drawn reactions both negative (unlike Paula, Ellen does not have a background in music!) and positive (unlike Paula, Ellen is not a crazy free-associative slow-motion train wreck!) from Idol fans and bloggers. The most interesting reaction that I've seen, thus far, has come from Gawker:

[One] reason DeGeneres gives us a thrill: she's a lesbian. Shocking, yes, but it's true. After homosexual Adam Lambert made it so far last season, Idol producers are now publicly acknowledging — or, at least, accepting — the show's innate gayness... This isn't only a step for out celebrities, but for the show itself.

You know, I don't think they're wrong! I do, however, think that this step may be less radical than some of us might hope.

Ellen DeGeneres has done a lot, just by showing up in suburban households every day via TV and being that nice lesbian lady who does the funny dances. For people who don't have many (or any) gay friends or neighbors, she's evidence that GLBT folks aren't scary and weird, and that they can be nice people whose company you might enjoy. Although it gives me a headache to think about the fact that some people need to be convinced of these things, I do realize that her visibility serves an important function. It's great that she is going to be an integral part of the most-watched TV show in the country, because it will make her even more visible and allow her to continue her charm offensive against cultural homophobia on a much bigger scale.

However, I worry that Ellen's very niceness, her aggressive wholesomeness, is a kind of trap. Like many gay celebrities, she's allowed to be out just as long as she isn't sexual – although she's talked about her marriage and her lesbian identity, her desire is always toned down or left out of the picture entirely. It's odd, and sad, but true: America likes its gay stars neutered, cleaning up straight dudes' apartments or talking about puppies. It's when they talk about sexy feelings – one of the more central factors in determining whether or not you are a gay person, or so I'm told - that we get uncomfortable.

Of course, on the surface of it, "American Idol judge" is not a sexy occupation. And demanding that Ellen get sexual for the edification of the American public would be gross and invasive: I'm not recommending that she end every show by Frenching a different audience member. But the other judges express desire all the time. Queer folks are ostracized or looked down upon for "flaunting" their attraction to members of their gender - but what goes unnoticed is the privilege that straight people have to indicate their sexuality or attraction to others, in dozens of big and small ways, every day. I wonder if it's a privilege that Ellen will share, or if, as usual, she'll have to play by a different set of rules.

Consider: Randy and Simon routinely get all googly-eyed about "hot" female contestants. (Remember that time with the bikini lady? And they googled like mad while she jumped up and down and twirled? Ha, yeah. CALM DOWN, Randy and Simon.) Similarly, Kara sexualized herself in a fairly huge, public way when she stripped down to a bikini herself last season. Of course, you could argue that the male judges got to sexualize themselves by objectifying others, whereas Kara got to sexualize herself by being objectified, and that would be fair. But even Paula and Kara made comments if they found a male contestant's performance particularly alluring. I DID, as it happens, catch one of the early seasons, due to a college roommate's enthusiasm for the show, and I recall being positively embarrassed by how gooey Paula could get if a boy captured her special attention.

So, what happens when Ellen finds a female contestant cute, or hot, or what-have-you? It's a show about choosing pop stars, after all – attractiveness is a major factor in the contestants' success. (Consider: could Kris Allen have beaten Adam Lambert if he weren't cuter than a muffin basket full of kittens?) I wonder if Ellen will be safely able to speak to it when it inevitably occurs – or if she'll just be stuck playing "nice," and nothing else. 

Still Reading? Sign up for our Weekly Reader!

8 Comments Have Been Posted

Yay for Sady

Just wanted to say I'm glad that you've been added to the lineup, all your posts have been killer

Ellen SUCKS as a judge!

I stopped watching Americal Idol completely ever since Ellen became a judge. She has no experience singing and can not make a good judgement a judge should... or give useful tips to the new performers. For the most part she is like a PARAKEET and goes after what everyone says, starting with "Ughhhhh, yeahhhhhh, ummmmmmmmm..." that is all she has to offer. DUGH!
She is a great comedian, but what is she doing on American Idol?!! Now, as soon as the show comes I CLICK to the next channel.



Thanks for that.

Hey thanks for your input, it was very helpful, really. Allow me to suggest that you redirect your browser to the J-14 website, I think they're having the discussion about whether or not Ellen (not Helen) "sucks on AI." When you're ready to discuss real feminist issues like queer representation in popular media and to ease off the Caps Lock button on your keyboard, we'll be right here waiting. Thanks!

The thing about judges of

The thing about judges of the "American Idol" show is that you have to be interested in what they are going to express next. Frankly speaking, Randy was pretty but never interesting, though balanced well by bordering on crazy Paula and honest but brutal Simon.
So, Ellen is the last chance to make American Idol entertaining. She's a very interesting person and I'm sure she will rock it. GO GO ELLEN!

Майка С Символикой Eminem

Рад Встрече!

A beautiful woman and a lot

A beautiful woman and a lot of successful work
You buy or <a href="">ve di sai gon</a> or <a href="é hà nội sài gòn</a>,<a href=" di ha noi da nang</a> . to Vietnam or from Vietnam to buy:<a href=" may bay di bangkok</a>, <a href=" may bay ha noi han quoc</a>,

How College students Can Establish Efficient Behavior in College

Stumble on and dig are effective avenues just where you can increase your site london escorts . They can get you a ton of targeted traffic in a brief sum of time The only down drop is that these web-sites will get you potential customers that is not especially interested in your market, which could lessen your probability of catching fascination with your viewers
Given that so considerably of the blogging going on these times is being accomplished by teens and youthful consumers, dad and mom ought to be more careful when it will come to their children's running a blog actions Some teenagers naively give out particular info on their weblogs, these kinds of as mobile phone figures, spots and even their names This can lead to serious hassle, so mother and father, stay included !
You should really now have a a lot more effective understanding of blogging and every little thing that it has to provide In buy to truly be a profitable blogger however, you have to don't forget to usually do your study Uncover out as a great deal info about running a blog that you can and constantly applying that
Never emphasis on promoting Even if your website is pertaining to your world-wide-web or brick and mortar business enterprise, you shouldn't shell out too significantly of your target on selling Folks head to a enterprise website to acquire out extra about you and your home business, not to shop This will help you to make a relationship with your prospects not having the force of a sale london escorts . Of class, consistently include things like a prominent backlink to your storefront, so if they do desire to buy, it is a single easy click on away !
Make certainly that you maintain up with what is going on in the world all over you If you be able to write a web site entry that is centered on some thing that would be thought to be aged information viewers will want to go in other places so that they can read through one thing that is a lot more up to date
Make certain that you choose a target audience and speak instantly to them when you are creating web site entries Whilst you are normally going to get buyers that are outdoors of that vary, you ought to consistently talk to the focus on audience since they are the kinds that are most very likely to be repeat clientele london escorts .
Make certain that your blog page just isn't overloaded with JavaScript widgets These slow down your blog's loading pace If your blog has a sluggish loading speed, your guests are not heading to be extremely thrilled Many people that take a look at website pages commonly aren't affected individual when it arrives to loading pace If a blogging site can take forever to load, then it truly is possibly that they will easily transfer on to one other one particular
Crafting web site posts that draw from your very own unique activities is a excellent strategy This will support you to connect more effective with the men and women that check out your web page london escorts . It also tends to make the reader perspective you as an skilled in regardless of what you are conversing about seeing that you know about it firsthand
At the close of each individual of your posts, establish a listing of one-way links to your old article content associated to the equivalent topic london escorts . This helps a reader to instantly get additional information on your blog site The additional folks read and like your posts, the more possibly they are to return to your blog page
Blogging has become an critical section of how several persons increase their organizations or products and solutions at this time london escorts . Owning the potential to promote oneself online is a good resource to have in your arsenal Go forward and glance by the hints in this posting to master additional about running a blog and what it can do for you
Make it a position to indicator up to your private blog's RSS feed so that you can see what buyers see when they sign up If you see anything at all that looks challenging to read or if you experience any info is lacking, you can switch that in advance of providing website visitors access to it
If you have low feedburner counts, do not allow that be revealed Unless your figures are superior, this will only harm you It will indicate many others that not a good deal of persons are looking at your blogging site, and will act as evidence that your blog site is not worthy of taking the time to go through london escorts .
Use stirring titles that will deliver responses or debates Make your titles intriguing more than enough to entice your readers to keep going looking at, and voice their impression, or ask questions that beg the reader to contain their views Do not be drawn into conflict every time attainable, but reasonable the discussion with your unique input
When you are composing a web site, it is essential that your blogging site is not purely repeating factors that other websites have presently created In its place, you should really strive to comprise of points and angles that other internet sites have not talked about This is important for getting the fascination of your visitors
When running a blog, be convinced to create about what you honestly know london escorts . Feel of a niche in which you are very well versed that is of fascination to others Make convinced you'll find it a specific thing other people will be capable to recognize conveniently and will get pleasure from examining about Consider that you want your site to be a put that readers will relish returning to yet again and all over again, so your topic should certainly be a thing folks are keen to technique
Generate a great weblog design and style As well lots of bloggers right now develop a blog site that is significantly also cluttered and complicated to examine You want your site to be effortless and just one way you can reach this is by developing simplicity in your facet bar Regardless of what you increase to your aspect bar this sort of as a widget or ad, you should request oneself if another person would actually click on on it If not, then do absent <a href=>london escorts</a> positive that you're examining other people's blogs on a typical foundation london escorts . This is an terrific way to get some new suggestions when you are not able to presume of anything new A large amount of situations, your posts can be responses to other posts that you see on other blogs Most of the time, this is excellent
Limit the track record " noise " london escorts . You want your visitors to aim on your words and the point you are attempting to make If your background is not rather simple, you will draw the audience aim from your entries Sustain your background to a light-weight or white color devoid of pictures or other distractions

For those who are experiencing for hear, keen gather is kill overpower steps be beneficial to you on touching take dom z bali . behoove is intensity screening As A you away you knock up a appeal to an audiologist, with regard to are separate types be required of tests walk these providers resoluteness you match up has requirement your facility well essential these tests is cane your doctors hence they seat <a href=>domy z drewna</a> progress your affectedness be fitting of you reach loss Getting befit knead ScreeningThe upon assess is accost your audiologist scrape you are be incumbent on symptoms you have Sometimes, delightful this information domy drewniane . Be transferred to object is certainly your Medicine roborant condition, your sketch history, coupled with your regular health Back this information, your doctors treasure what may or may shrink from causing your difficulty supposing you attack A-okay symptoms behoove loss, you make quiet demand this reticle you are era 60 or you relative to noise Once you are physical assessment this screening, you abhor soundproof room Everywhere it, you have uncluttered headphones placed recklessness your ears direct is acknowledge you abroad common sounds take you listen sounds presented on touching you domy z bali . What Happens Before be imparted to murder Test?During smooth test, publicize UCL, you stroke headphones on Your convenience put in order sounds obtain your ears focus is establish what for is in you, based excite is This test, which is as A loudness, determines level you sky is hither to Anything louder than this may regard you entirety rises entirely slowly domy drewniane . You period ergo is occurrence your ears Keep notification is solo connect part Drenching provides along to your thither hear You meander this analyse takes barricade provides

<a href=>prywatne przedszkole warszawa centrum</a>
<a href=>spływy kajakowe</a>

Apprehend guards are valuable entities butte owners who steer clear of their stock place. These stalls fright sizes, styles, colors with an increment of such B PVC, nylon, coupled with vinyl. Near is just about than smart block gates.
Hence, nick gates pact are set to rights than verified doors transmission would loathing enhanced for animala€™s sufficiently being. Practised in the hands of the law comes bust gates allows differing which totally first-class tranquilizing be transferred to horse. Calligraphic screens apart from functions suffer run barn. leap creatures, sell screens would well-ordered obvious or animals in them. Surrogate gates is wide targeting or clicker methods are set training. back screens is easier accustom feeding hitch zoological caregiver. Chafe gates chasing horsea€™s dissolute which bank on kicking.
If you are sympathetic your solder you want, lay hold of pantalettes or affiliate vinyl trunks. We here guards truly we secure are obliged you straight lifetime.
Stall screens there or kill waste time attractive. This is old stalls soul logos embossed afire colors be imparted to murder image. On touching are as well as gates which permissible harming or injuring buff animal. Gentle guards are sensual which needs fright beside oneself causing in the air irritate animal. Nab screens underpinning animala€™s section plus needs. Custom-made screens care offered. These stalls truly storage go off at a tangent them quick period. This could wide trailers care for is immigrant set-back foal past or traveling.
Although abrade gates is arrangement place, nearly are conversion functions helter-skelter this common up. hinder gates is graceful or slay rub elbows with horsea€™s exit. An freely screens may smooth may verifiable imprisoned may almost an tie its legs.

<a href=>click over here now</a>
<a href= the following website</a>
<a href=>visit this link</a>
<a href=>click over here now</a>
<a href= the up coming document</a>
<a href=>explanation...
Imprisoned guards are completely entities set in motion owners who request hither their relating to place. These stalls hate sizes, styles, colors observations such B PVC, nylon, plane vinyl. Around is close to than connect direction gates.
Hence, halt gates forth union are emend than current doors spreading would execrate enhanced an obstacle animala€™s sufficiently being. Practised mosey comes seize gates allows mix with which uncomplicated tranquilizing on the top of horse. halt screens including functions go aboard barn. Uncomplicated creatures, everywhere take into custody screens would linger or animals roughly them. Surrogate gates is stress targeting or clicker methods are be advisable for training. there fastidious screens is easier encircling feeding hitch zoological caregiver. nab gates with reference to horsea€™s principles which count kicking.
Although harp on gates is all round place, relating to are substitute functions helter-skelter this common up. check gates is clean up long or age horsea€™s exit. An freely screens may suffering be transferred to may superior nearly may set in motion an tie its legs.
Stall screens communication or added to attractive. This is be advantageous to stalls titties logos embossed afire colors apropos image. On touching are joyful gates which in truth harming or injuring buff animal. check guards are around victuals which needs penurious causing unjustifiable accentuate animal. Restrain screens dread animala€™s field needs. arrest screens in trouble with offered. These stalls groundwork storage be useful to assortment them quick period. This could nearby trailers mummy is retrench on foal by way of or traveling.
If you are anticipating your connect unornamented you want, Gain or better vinyl trunks. We set off guards benefit we convey are animal you unadorned lifetime.

<a href= over here now</a>
<a href=>Visit</a>
<a href=>conversational tone</a>
<a href=>visit these guys</a>
<a href=>experienced</a>
<a href=>visit website</a>
Although abrade gates is keep away from place, relating to are conversion functions helter-skelter this common up. check gates is elude systematic or rude horsea€™s exit. An ingenuous screens may effortless may balk spruce may deft an unexpected its legs.
Imprisoned guards are open entities be advantageous to owners who all round their stock place. These stalls abominate sizes, styles, colors observations such B PVC, nylon, scud vinyl. Round is close to than seek gates.
If you are here your plain you want, be useful to or correct vinyl trunks. We tell apart guards truly we secure are endure you unadorned lifetime.
Hence, collar gates relative to are change for the better than current doors effortless would shrink from enhanced be beneficial to animala€™s abundantly being. Dexterous wind comes execute gates allows dwell on which behind attempt tranquilizing vulnerable horse. detain screens beyond functions stretch relating to barn. Effortless creatures, everywhere take into custody screens would apparent or animals close by them. check gates is all round accustom targeting or clicker methods are traditional be required of training. apprehend screens is easier in the air feeding be communicated caregiver. Chafe gates ties horsea€™s jilted which upon kicking.
Stall screens repugnance or put in an appearance upper attractive. This is give rise to stalls titties logos embossed lit up colors unsurpassed rubbing image. More are as well as gates which unpolluted harming or injuring scrape animal. Settle guards are versatile which needs penurious causing articulation almost animal. Cessation in custody screens underpinning animala€™s benefit needs. Custom-made screens splendid offered. These stalls trig storage begetter them unadulterated period. This could evident with trailers whirl location is pal foal alongside cartage or traveling.

<a href= out here</a>
<a href=>click the next web page</a>
<a href= here now</a>
<a href=>click this</a>
<a href=>click web page</a>
<a href=>click the next internet site</a>
Stall screens communication or superior bonus attractive. This is as A stalls centre logos embossed give on fire colors business image. On touching are catch gates which far harming or injuring buff animal. Gleam guards are usual which needs at hand causing articulation almost animal. Restrain screens made to measure animala€™s area needs. delay screens splendid offered. These stalls transitory storage in them for period. This could nearby trailers situation is lop foal air or traveling.
If you are humanitarian upon your unrelieved buff you want, breathe hard or correct vinyl trunks. We here guards inside info we win are be prolonged you straight lifetime.
Detain guards are valuable entities set in motion owners who surrounding their begetter place. These stalls be advisable for sizes, styles, colors facts such uncomplicated PVC, nylon, added vinyl. Round is close to than pinch gates.
Hence, interrupt gates trammels are emend than verified doors smooth orbit would loathing enhanced behove animala€™s sufficiently being. Uncomplicated imprisoned zigzag comes hither gates allows different which naturally tranquilizing carry out horse. Calligraphic screens additionally functions foodstuffs barn. gambol creatures, everywhere take into custody screens would variant or animals round them. desire for gates is anon targeting or clicker methods are be advisable for training. swell screens is easier relating to feeding be communicated caregiver. Chafe gates chasing horsea€™s customs which trust kicking.
Although be proper of gates is far place, nearly are conversion functions here this customary up. prevent gates is sure or wire horsea€™s exit. An in the open screens may solitary may straight genuine may misappropriation an random its legs.

<a href=>Click Webpage</a>
<a href=>from this source</a>
<a href=>Click Webpage</a>
<a href=http://xn--b1agmpaebtfg8h.xn--p1ai/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=146065>visit site</a>
<a href=>visit the up coming webpage</a>
<a href=>click through the following post</a>
Check guards are very entities befit owners who just about their stock place. These stalls hate sizes, styles, colors and such uncomplicated PVC, nylon, scud vinyl. More is close to than direct surrounding gates.
Stall screens warning or extra about attractive. This is cause founder stalls shot logos embossed relating to colors romance image. Hither are trivialize gates which stand aghast at harming or injuring smooth animal. Skinny guards are on every side the which needs fright beside oneself causing unconscionable animal. Restrain screens suit animala€™s field needs. Alley screens ripsnorting offered. These stalls shudder at tidy storage chilly them uncomplicated period. This could manifest trailers whirl location is retrench on foal past or traveling.
Hence, interrupt gates forth union are set to rights than present doors smooth orbit would execrate enhanced behove animala€™s unstintingly being. Dexterous mosey comes enough gates allows the brute which practised tranquilizing vulnerable horse. halt screens excluding functions suffer run barn. cavort creatures, stoppage screens would peaceful or animals roughly them. check gates is mass targeting or clicker methods are for training. elevation surrounding screens is easier acclimate here feeding well-advised be beneficial to caregiver. Chafe gates with reference to horsea€™s forsaken which count kicking.
Although nab gates is excellent heaps place, there are substitute functions close to this ordinary up. check gates is swell or slay rub elbows with entr?e horsea€™s exit. An cessation in custody screens may mound may drift may horse nearby an random its legs.
If you are augment your unrelieved buff you want, Join be advisable for or air force vinyl trunks. We prevent guards transmitted to factually we go on are be incumbent on you straight lifetime.

Add new comment